• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

Suggestion Free Backtesting Service Data Quality 99.90%

Hi Brekz1, maybe you can explain how traders can know whether it's Scam EA or Not.
I'm sure lots of newbie here very excited when seeing a crazy BT result such as Algo.
As for the report, I think it's quite alright for Algo with reasonable DD.
Yet, It doesn't perform well on real account.

Hi NeoBatavia

1) i dont know how to know whether its scam EA or not
2) i dont said if Algo is scam EA

my comment for Umesh is to warning us,
if evaluate the EA just base on final balance, its dangerous,
if we always act like this, we will ends on scam EA,
atleast there are some factor need to be concern.

what points need to be considered is i have already post that.

lets talk about Algo,
see RD, its about 50%, Loss trade 65%, avg.consecutive wins, avg.consecutive loss, max.consecutive loss
i will not put this on demo or live account
but maybe different setting give better result
this is why i dont say that Algo is scam EA

see the result below, i just change one parameter, its give RD and DD just 10%
but still have bad avg.consecutive wins, avg.consecutive loss, and loss trade 47%
the result is drop from millions dollars to just around 5000 for 5 years test with start balance 1000
try first on demo
 

Attachments

  • screenshot-{domain} {date} {time}.png
    screenshot-{domain} {date} {time}.png
    91.5 KB · Views: 534
Hi NeoBatavia

lets talk about Algo,
see RD, its about 50%, Loss trade 65%, avg.consecutive wins, avg.consecutive loss, max.consecutive loss
i will not put this on demo or live account
but maybe different setting give better result
this is why i dont say that Algo is scam EA

see the result below, i just change one parameter, its give RD and DD just 10%
but still have bad avg.consecutive wins, avg.consecutive loss, and loss trade 47%
the result is drop from millions dollars to just around 5000 for 5 years test with start balance 1000
try first on demo


Aha... This is what I mean Brekz1.
A good analysis, where I'm sure most newbie just see a graph that's going up (such as martingale) without considering other factors that you mention on the above.

Excellent tips.
 
Aha... This is what I mean Brekz1.
A good analysis, where I'm sure most newbie just see a graph that's going up (such as martingale) without considering other factors that you mention on the above.

Excellent tips.

we must remember,
its just for evaluate the EA profitable or not, just base on strategy tester report
but dont forget about external factor, like, spread on report versus spread on your broker, requote, loss connection, widen spread, and so many other factor
 
we must remember,
its just for evaluate the EA profitable or not, just base on strategy tester report
but dont forget about external factor, like, spread on report versus spread on your broker, requote, loss connection, widen spread, and so many other factor[/Q
100% true
specially requotes and delay factor major weapons of broker to fail any profitable EA.

brekz 1 can you suggest any broker suitable for asian having less requotes issues.
 
100% true
specially requotes and delay factor major weapons of broker to fail any profitable EA.

brekz 1 can you suggest any broker suitable for asian having less requotes issues.

im sorry, i cant give you any suggestion about choosing broker:)
because it leads to advertising things.

but you can googling it, there are alot of review about broker
or you just see on here:
screenshot-soehoe.com 2016-03-18 11-55-58.png
 
Hi Brekz
I can't view ur any posting
when i saw ur old posting in Alerts section its look like as in attached file
& i cant saw ur new post
Regards
Umesh
 

Attachments

  • Brekz.jpg
    Brekz.jpg
    20.6 KB · Views: 249
Hi Brekz
I can't view ur any posting
when i saw ur old posting in Alerts section its look like as in attached file
& i cant saw ur new post
Regards
Umesh
is because you "ignore" me

maybe you accidentaly hit that button
see picture below
 

Attachments

  • screenshot-soehoe.com 2016-03-18 13-35-04.png
    screenshot-soehoe.com 2016-03-18 13-35-04.png
    186.4 KB · Views: 204
Thank u Brekz
Yes I accidentally hit that button
I remove from ignore list
Now i can see ur post

Regards
 
Please make backtest of the last version of XMT-Scalper with this preset
Pair: EURUSD M1, spread 14
 


Try also with preset (Set_2) and spread 8


Hi, here are your BT.. :)
But i have very big doubts, if it would work in real.
And all depends on the spread, as you can see dramatically in example 2 + 3 which is the same, but with Spread 8 and Spread 14 . :think:
Common Parameters: Equity 10k, M1, October 2015 till now:

Set1: Spread: 14
StrategyTester set1 EU M1 5month P20k 151001 - 160311.jpg

Set2 Spread: 14

StrategyTester set2 spread8 EU M1 5month P253k 151001 - 160311.jpg

Set2, Spread: 14
StrategyTester set2 spread14 EU M1 5month P18k 151001 - 160311.jpg
 
Pair : EURUSD
TF : M30
Balance : 10.000
Setting : setfile 1&2
Period : 2011-2015 (5 tahun)
mardin
makasi om, tuh ea seharga $3000 di mql5 om, itu full vers. Tapi blum yg terbaru, tapi kayakx hampir sama aja deh hasilx kalo settx benar, buat tman2 trader bisa nyobain sensasix, salam profit
 
can it open trade on demo account? is yes, you can use EA copier to live account
Itu full vers om, tpi runx di 902 920, smoga tman2 sukses menggunakan eax, mudah2an aja brokerx gak nakal
 
Aha... This is what I mean Brekz1.
A good analysis, where I'm sure most newbie just see a graph that's going up (such as martingale) without considering other factors that you mention on the above.

Excellent tips.
Algo
https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/145833
 
Hi NeoBatavia

1) i dont know how to know whether its scam EA or not
2) i dont said if Algo is scam EA

my comment for Umesh is to warning us,
if evaluate the EA just base on final balance, its dangerous,
if we always act like this, we will ends on scam EA,
atleast there are some factor need to be concern.

what points need to be considered is i have already post that.

lets talk about Algo,
see RD, its about 50%, Loss trade 65%, avg.consecutive wins, avg.consecutive loss, max.consecutive loss
i will not put this on demo or live account
but maybe different setting give better result
this is why i dont say that Algo is scam EA

see the result below, i just change one parameter, its give RD and DD just 10%
but still have bad avg.consecutive wins, avg.consecutive loss, and loss trade 47%
the result is drop from millions dollars to just around 5000 for 5 years test with start balance 1000
try first on demo
Om klo bisa mnta tolong cariin settx biar lebih save, acuanx pngujianx 5 taon, kalo omx gak sibuk aja, hehehhe ngarep
 
Back
Top